Chapter 5: Overview of the Workers Compensation Marketplace

Overview

Employers subject to workers compensation laws must ensure that they provide benefits to employees who are injured on the job. This obligation can be fulfilled in one of two ways:

Purchasing Workers Compensation Insurance: The most common method, where employers buy insurance policies from licensed providers to cover these benefits.

Self-Insuring: An option available to larger employers with sufficient financial resources to directly pay benefits, provided they obtain state authorization to do so.

While most businesses opt for purchasing insurance, self-insurance is a viable alternative for large companies or groups of smaller companies that can pool resources.

Workers Compensation Insurance Markets

The availability and source of workers compensation insurance vary depending on the state in which the business operates. The key sources are:

Monopolistic State Funds: In states like North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, and Wyoming, workers compensation insurance must be purchased through a state-run fund. Private insurance companies are not involved in these markets, which are known as monopolistic funds. Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands also operate under similar systems. Employers in these regions have no access to private insurers for workers compensation and must rely on the state fund.

Voluntary Private Market: In all states except the monopolistic ones, employers can purchase workers compensation insurance from private insurers. Nearly all insurance companies that offer other types of business insurance, such as commercial property or liability insurance, also provide workers compensation coverage. However, some insurers may choose not to offer workers compensation policies in certain states or to specific businesses, particularly if the risk is high or the business has a poor loss history.

Competitive State Funds: In 19 states, there is an additional option to buy workers compensation insurance from a state-run competitive fund, which operates alongside private insurers. These funds are designed to foster competition and potentially lower insurance costs for businesses. However, a limitation of these funds is that they may not fully cover liabilities under the workers compensation laws of other states.

Residual Market Plans: For employers unable to secure insurance through the voluntary market, state residual market facilities provide a safety net. These plans, also known as assigned risk plans, allocate high-risk policies to insurers operating within the state. Rates in these plans are typically higher than in the voluntary market, and any associated losses are shared among all workers compensation insurers in the state based on market share.

Alternatives to Insurance

Some employers may opt to self-insure, either individually or as part of a group, to meet state workers compensation requirements. This alternative is generally reserved for larger businesses with the financial capacity to handle potential liabilities.

Individual Self-Insurance: Permitted in all states except North Dakota and Wyoming, individual self-insurance allows businesses to pay workers compensation benefits directly to employees. To qualify, employers must demonstrate to regulators that they have the financial strength to meet their obligations, often requiring the posting of security and the purchase of excess insurance.

Group Self-Insurance: Smaller businesses may band together to form self-insurance groups, which are allowed in 37 states. These groups provide a way for smaller entities to self-insure by pooling resources, though members may still face assessments if the group's costs exceed its reinsurance coverage. Group members are often required to be in the same industry and must operate within a single state.

In summary, the workers compensation marketplace offers a variety of options tailored to different business sizes, risk profiles, and regulatory environments, ranging from purchasing traditional insurance to self-insuring individually or as part of a group.