Chapter 4: Insurance Coverage under Federal Acts
Overview
In addition to state workers compensation laws, several federal workers compensation statutes govern specific categories of workers, providing them with benefits for job-related injuries or illnesses. Employees covered by federal workers compensation laws are generally not covered by state workers compensation laws.
Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act (LHWCA)
The Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act (LHWCA) was enacted by the U.S. Congress in 1927. This law was established after court rulings denied state workers compensation benefits to maritime employees injured on navigable waters under federal jurisdiction. The LHWCA provides compensation and medical benefits to most maritime workers who suffer work-related injuries, disabilities, or deaths, excluding masters or crew members of a vessel.
Key Challenges and Amendments
After its passage, the LHWCA faced several challenges:
1. Jurisdictional Confusion: Courts struggled to determine whether state workers compensation laws or the LHWCA applied in certain cases, as the Act did not clearly define jurisdictional boundaries.
2. Legal Actions Against Ship Owners: Injured maritime workers frequently filed LHWCA claims and sued ship owners under general maritime law, alleging "unseaworthiness" of the vessel as the cause of injury. This led to ship owners requiring maritime employers to sign hold-harmless agreements, creating further legal complexities.
3. Third-Party-Over Actions: Ship owners sued by injured workers would often counter-sue the worker's employer for contributory negligence, complicating the legal landscape.
1972 LHWCA Amendments
To address these issues, Congress amended the LHWCA in 1972, implementing several key changes:
Restriction on Lawsuits: Injured maritime workers covered by the LHWCA were prohibited from suing vessel owners on the grounds of "unseaworthiness," though negligence suits against third parties, including vessel owners, were still allowed.
Invalidation of Hold-Harmless Agreements: Such agreements between maritime employers and vessel owners were rendered unenforceable.
Ban on Third-Party-Over Suits: These types of lawsuits were prohibited.
Increased Benefit Levels: The amendment raised LHWCA benefits, often exceeding those offered under state compensation laws.
Establishment of "Status" and "Situs" Tests: These tests became prerequisites for LHWCA coverage, defining who is covered under the Act (status) and where the injury must occur (situs).
The "status" test defines an "employee" as anyone engaged in maritime employment, including longshoremen, ship repairmen, shipbuilders, and shipbreakers, but excluding masters, crew members, and certain other categories. The "situs" test stipulates that coverage applies if the injury occurs on navigable waters or adjoining areas customarily used for maritime activities.
1984 LHWCA Amendment
In 1984, the LHWCA was amended again, primarily to limit the scope of coverage and address unintended expansions due to liberal court interpretations. The law was renamed the "Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act," and specific exclusions were added for certain types of workers, such as clerical staff, marina employees not involved in construction, and those employed in recreational operations.
2009 LHWCA Amendment
The most recent amendment in 2009 further refined the Act by excluding from its coverage workers involved in the construction of recreational vessels under 65 feet in length or in the repair or dismantling of recreational vessels of any size, provided they are covered by a state workers compensation program.
Insuring LHWCA Exposures
Employers must secure LHWCA coverage either through an authorized insurance carrier or by becoming an authorized self-insurer. Failure to do so can result in significant fines and potential imprisonment. Corporations are held accountable, with their officers personally liable for compensation or benefits under the Act.
Some employers, particularly those without known LHWCA exposures, may find it prudent to add an LHWCA endorsement to their workers compensation policy to cover unexpected exposures. This endorsement can often be secured for a minimal additional premium.
Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act (OCSLA)
The Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, passed in 1953, extends LHWCA benefits to workers injured or killed on fixed structures attached to the Outer Continental Shelf, primarily for natural resource exploration or development. Employers can obtain coverage by adding the OCSLA endorsement to their workers compensation policy.
Defense Base Act
The Defense Base Act extends LHWCA benefits to civilian employees working on U.S. military, air, or naval bases acquired from foreign governments after January 1, 1940. It also covers employees engaged in public works projects outside the continental United States. Coverage is secured through a Defense Base Act endorsement.
Nonappropriated Fund Instrumentalities Act (NFIA)
The NFIA applies LHWCA benefits to civilian employees working for certain U.S. military-affiliated organizations, such as exchanges and ship stores. Coverage is obtained by adding an NFIA endorsement to the workers compensation policy.
Federal Employees Compensation Act (FECA)
The Federal Employees Compensation Act (FECA) provides workers compensation benefits to civilian employees of the federal government. The federal government self-insures these benefits, and no NCCI endorsement is available.
Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1969 (FMSHA)
The Federal Mine Safety and Health Act, particularly Title IV (the Black Lung Benefits Act), provides benefits to coal miners disabled by pneumoconiosis and their dependents. The Act mandates that coal mine operators secure benefits through insurance or self-insurance. Coverage is available via an FMSHA endorsement to the workers compensation policy.
Federal Employers Liability Laws
In addition to no-fault workers compensation laws, several federal statutes provide a cause of action for employees to sue their employers for negligence or unseaworthiness:
Federal Employers Liability Act (FELA): Allows railroad workers to sue their employers for negligence.
General Maritime Law: Provides remedies for seamen injured due to unseaworthy conditions or while in service of a vessel.
Death on the High Seas Act: Permits beneficiaries to sue for wrongful death occurring on the high seas due to unseaworthiness or negligence.
The Jones Act: Extends FELA to seamen, allowing them to sue for injuries caused by employer negligence.
Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSAWPA)
The MSAWPA imposes specific requirements on employers of migrant and seasonal agricultural workers, including job information disclosure, safety standards, and vehicle insurance. Violations can result in sanctions, and workers can sue for damages. Amendments to the Act have clarified that workers compensation benefits are the exclusive remedy for injuries if coverage is provided.
