Chapter 5: Causes of Loss—Special Form

The Causes of Loss—Special Form (CP 10 30) stands out as the most comprehensive among the three causes of loss forms, often referred to as an "all risks" form. Unlike the basic and broad forms that list specific covered perils, the special form covers all direct physical loss unless explicitly excluded or limited. This broad coverage necessitates a more extensive list of exclusions and limitations, which define the true scope of protection.

Advantages of the Special Form

The special causes of loss form offers several key advantages over the basic and broad forms:

- Theft Coverage: It covers most theft scenarios, except employee theft, unauthorized property transfers, voluntary parting with property, and theft of building materials. The basic and broad forms, by contrast, only cover theft related to looting during riots.

- Burden of Proof: With an all risks policy like the special form, the insurer must prove that a loss is excluded to deny a claim. In contrast, named perils policies place the burden on the insured to prove that a loss is covered.

- Additional Coverage Extensions: This form includes two unique coverage extensions—property in transit and glass—which are not present in the basic or broad forms.

The Role of Exclusions and Limitations

While the special form provides broad coverage, understanding its exclusions and limitations is crucial. The form’s exclusions are grouped into three categories, with each group containing specific provisions that narrow the scope of coverage.

Group 1 Exclusions: These are the same as in the basic and broad forms and are subject to an "anti-concurrent causation" clause, meaning if an excluded peril contributes to a loss, coverage is denied even if other covered perils are involved. Key exclusions include:

- Water (e.g., floods, sewer backups)
- Earth movement (e.g., earthquakes, landslides)
- Fungus, wet rot, dry rot, and bacteria
- Ordinance or law compliance
- Governmental action
- Nuclear hazards
- War and military action
- Utility services interruption
- Cyber incidents (via mandatory endorsement)
- Terrorism (if added by endorsement)

Group 2 Exclusions: Unlike Group 1, these exclusions are not subject to anti-concurrent causation and often have exceptions that allow coverage for ensuing loss from covered perils. Examples include:

- Artificially generated electrical energy affecting devices (ensuing fire covered)
- Explosion of steam boilers or turbines owned or operated by the insured (ensuing fire or combustion explosion covered)
- Wear and tear, rust, and mechanical breakdown (ensuing loss from a covered peril covered)
- Precipitation damage to property in the open (excluded)
- Pollutant release (excluded unless caused by a specified cause of loss)

Group 3 Exclusions: Unique to the special form, these exclusions address causes that courts have previously identified as concurrent, unexcluded causes of loss in all risks policies. They include:

- Acts or decisions by any person or organization
- Faulty planning, design, or maintenance
- Weather conditions that combine with an excluded peril to cause damage

Additionally, there is a specific exclusion for damage to products caused by production errors.v

Limitations

The special form also imposes several limitations, restricting coverage for certain types of loss or specific property. Notable limitations include:

- Internally Caused Damage to Boilers: Damage from internal conditions is excluded, except for combustion explosions.

- Precipitation Damage: No coverage for rain, snow, or ice damage to building interiors or contents unless caused by damage to the roof or walls from an unexcluded peril.

- Building Materials Theft: Excludes coverage for stolen building materials unless they are held for sale.

- Missing Property: No coverage for property that is missing without physical evidence of what happened.

- Unauthorized Property Transfer: No coverage if property is transferred based on unauthorized instructions.

- Named Perils for Certain Property: Certain fragile items, builders' tools off-premises, and animals are only covered for specific perils.

Additional Coverages and Extensions

The special form includes two additional coverages and three coverage extensions:

- Collapse Coverage: Covers collapse due to specified causes, such as hidden decay or defective materials.

- Fungus Coverage: Provides up to $15,000 for loss due to fungus, rot, or bacteria.

- Property in Transit: Covers personal property in transit for specified perils, with a $5,000 limit.

- Glass Coverage: Extends to temporary plates, boarding up, and removing obstructions to repair glass.

- Water Damage Tear-Out: Covers the cost of tearing out and replacing parts of a building to repair systems that caused covered water damage.

Water Damage Coverage Overview

The special form includes multiple provisions restricting water damage coverage, such as exclusions for flood and underground water, continuous leakage, and water discharge from freezing pipes. However, it does offer coverage for water damage caused by leakage from systems or appliances under specific conditions.

In summary, while the special causes of loss form provides broad coverage, its extensive exclusions and limitations make it essential to understand what is—and isn’t—covered. This careful delineation of coverage ensures that the special form offers protection against a wide range of risks while managing the insurer's exposure to losses.