Chapter 4: Covered Causes of Loss - Basic and Broad Forms

Property insurance protects against losses caused by specific perils, or "covered causes of loss." These can be categorized in two ways:

  1. Named Perils: The policy lists specific causes of loss it covers.
  2. All Risks: The policy covers all causes except those explicitly excluded.

Most commercial property policies today use the "all risks" approach, but named perils coverage remains common in some cases.

A standard commercial property policy is modular, meaning it combines various forms to create comprehensive coverage. Among these is the causes of loss form, which specifies what perils are covered and any associated limitations or exclusions. There are three primary causes of loss forms:

- Basic Form (CP 10 10)
- Broad Form (CP 10 20)
- Special Form (CP 10 30)

The Basic and Broad forms cover named perils, while the Special form provides all risks coverage. This chapter focuses on the Basic and Broad forms.

Common Causes of Loss in Basic and Broad Forms

Both the Basic and Broad forms cover similar perils, with the Broad form offering a few additional protections. Here's an overview:

Covered by Both Forms:

- Fire
- Lightning
- Explosion
- Windstorm or hail
- Smoke
- Aircraft or vehicles
- Riot or civil commotion
- Vandalism
- Sprinkler leakage
- Sinkhole collapse
- Volcanic action
- Limited coverage for fungus, wet rot, dry rot, and bacteria

Additional Coverage in Broad Form

- Falling objects
- Weight of snow, ice, or sleet
- Water damage from certain sources
- Collapse due to specific causes

Fire and Lightning: Simple and straightforward, these perils are covered with no additional conditions.

Explosion: Covers combustion explosions but excludes damage from safety valve ruptures or steam boiler explosions, which require separate equipment breakdown coverage.

Windstorm and Hail: Excludes damage from frost, cold, and snow unless the building's exterior is first damaged by wind or hail.

Smoke: Covers smoke damage not caused by fire, but excludes smoke from agricultural or industrial activities.

Aircraft or Vehicles: Protects against damage from aircraft, vehicles, or objects falling from them, except for vehicles owned or operated by the insured.

Riot and Civil Commotion: Includes damage from public disturbances and looting during such events.

Vandalism: Covers intentional damage but excludes theft, except for damage caused by burglar entry or exit.

Sprinkler Leakage: Covers accidental discharge from fire sprinkler systems, including repair costs if necessary.

Sinkhole Collapse: Covers land collapse due to natural underground voids but excludes human-made cavities.

Volcanic Action: Covers damage from volcanic eruptions, excluding cleanup of ash or dust from undamaged property.

Fungus, Wet Rot, Dry Rot, and Bacteria: Coverage is severely limited, primarily applying to damage resulting from covered perils other than fire or lightning.

Additional Coverage in Broad Form

Falling Objects: Covers damage to buildings or contents if the exterior is first damaged by the falling object.

Weight of Snow, Ice, or Sleet: Excludes damage to property in the open.

Water Damage: Covers accidental discharge from plumbing or HVAC systems but excludes gradual leakage, freezing (without proper precautions), or water from sump systems.

Collapse: Provides coverage for sudden collapse caused by specific perils, such as weight of rain or hidden decay.

Exclusions in Basic and Broad Forms

Exclusions are divided into two groups:

Group 1 Exclusions: These include anti-concurrent causation language, meaning no coverage applies if the excluded peril is involved, even if another covered peril also contributed to the loss.

Examples include:

- Water (flood, mudslide, sewer backup)
- Earth movement (earthquake, landslide)
- Ordinance or law
- Governmental action
- Nuclear hazard
- War and military action
- Utility services interruption
- Cyber incidents
- Terrorism (can be excluded by endorsement)

Group 2 Exclusions: These do not include anti-concurrent causation language and often have exceptions for ensuing losses caused by covered perils. Examples include:

- Artificially generated electrical energy
- Explosion of steam boilers owned by the insured
- Mechanical breakdown
- Neglect to preserve property

Additionally, the Basic form includes specific exclusions for water pipe ruptures and leaks from appliances unless caused by a covered peril.

Limitations

Both forms have a limitation that restricts coverage for animals to cases where they are killed by a covered peril or need to be destroyed due to a covered loss. Standard policies provide limited coverage for animals, typically when they are part of the insured's inventory or are being boarded for others.

This streamlined approach ensures clarity on what perils are covered and highlights the importance of understanding exclusions and limitations in your commercial property policy.