Chapter 10: Experience Rating

Overview

Experience rating is a method used to adjust insurance premiums based on an employer’s actual loss history relative to the expected losses within their industry classification. This system incentivizes employers to maintain a strong safety record by rewarding those with better-than-average loss experience and penalizing those with worse-than-average experience. The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) primarily compiles the data used to calculate these experience modifiers.

Experience rating is largely driven by loss frequency rather than loss severity. This approach ensures that employers are not unduly penalized for infrequent but severe losses that may be beyond their control. Instead, it emphasizes the importance of maintaining a safe work environment to minimize the number of claims.

When an employer’s loss experience is more favorable than the industry average, they receive a credit modifier (less than 1.0), reducing their insurance premium. Conversely, unfavorable loss experience results in a debit modifier (greater than 1.0), increasing their premium. The experience modifier is applied to the standard premium as a multiplier to determine the final premium.

Eligibility

Experience rating is mandatory in most states for employers who meet certain premium thresholds. Smaller employers are typically not experience rated because their loss experience is less credible due to the limited size of their exposure units (e.g., payroll). The experience rating process becomes applicable when an employer's total premiums over the last two years, or the average annual premium over more than two years, exceeds a specified amount.

Experience Rating Period

The experience rating period usually covers three full years, ending one year before the effective date of the experience modifier. This period excludes the most recent year because losses from that year are often still developing and are not yet fully credible.

Ownership Implications

The ownership structure of an organization can significantly impact its experience rating. When entities are under common majority ownership, their loss experiences may be combined for experience rating purposes. This combination can have substantial effects on the final experience modifier, depending on the loss histories of the entities involved.

For majority ownership to be considered, one person, group, or corporation must own more than 50% of each entity. The rules for combining entities are strict, ensuring that only those with a genuine ownership connection are considered.

Changes in Ownership

Changes in ownership can result in the reassignment of an entity’s loss experience for experience rating. If there is a material change in ownership—defined as a change where the final owners collectively owned less than 33⅓% of the entity before the change or where prior owners collectively own less than 50% after the change—the experience modifier may be affected.

In cases where the operations of the entity also change significantly, leading to a new governing classification, the previous loss experience might be excluded from future experience ratings.

Data Collection for Experience Rating

The calculation of experience modifiers relies on data collected through workers compensation statistical plans, which require insurers to file exposure, premium, and loss data for each policy. This data is reported through a unit statistical report, or unit stat card, which must be filed within 20 months of the policy's effective date.

Insurers are required to submit subsequent reports at 12-month intervals to update loss data, especially for policies that are experience rated. These subsequent reports continue until all claims are resolved or until the insurer and insured agree not to make any further adjustments.

Application and Changes to Experience Modifiers

When an insured qualifies for experience rating, an experience modifier is issued for a 12-month period, beginning on the anniversary rating date, which usually coincides with the policy's effective date. If a modifier is issued late, or if there is a change in the insured’s operations, the experience modifier may be revised retroactively, depending on the circumstances.

Modifiers that decrease premiums are applied retroactively, while those that increase premiums may be applied retroactively or prospectively, depending on when the change is made and the reasons for the change.

Reading the Experience Modification Worksheet

The experience modification worksheet is a critical document that details the payroll and claims data used to calculate an employer’s experience modifier. The worksheet includes information on the industry classification, expected losses, and actual claims data. Understanding how to read this worksheet is essential for employers to verify the accuracy of their experience modifier and to identify areas for improvement in their loss control programs.

Controlling Experience Modifiers

Employers can take several steps to control their experience modifiers:

- Implementing a robust loss control program focused on reducing loss frequency.

- Reviewing and updating loss reserves before the insurer submits the unit stat card.

- Requesting and reviewing unit stat cards before they are submitted to NCCI.

- Preparing a test modifier in advance to estimate renewal premiums.

- Verifying the accuracy of experience modifier calculations against loss reports and premium audits.

- Understanding the implications of ownership changes on the experience modifier.

- Keeping track of subrogation recoveries and requesting changes to modifiers when they occur.

- Recalculating experience modifiers if the insured’s operations are reclassified.

By taking these actions, employers can better manage their workers compensation costs and improve their experience rating over time.