Chapter 11: Employee Leasing

Overview

Employee leasing, which began gaining traction in the late 1970s, was initially popular due to two significant advantages—one related to pension plans and the other to workers compensation premium manipulation. The former was legally permitted until changes in tax laws, while the latter was often an abuse of the insurance system.

The Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 allowed employers to exclude leased employees from their pension plans if the leasing company funded a pension with a minimum contribution of 7.5% of each employee’s total compensation. This "safe harbor arrangement" enabled employers to offer more generous pensions to select employees without compromising their tax-favored status under the Employers Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). However, the 1986 Tax Reform Act changed this by requiring that if leased employees made up more than 20% of an employer’s total workforce, they had to be included in the ERISA qualification requirements.

Another major advantage in the 1980s was the ability to manipulate the workers compensation insurance system, a practice known as "mod renting." Employers with poor loss experience could transfer their employees to a leasing company with a better experience modifier, thereby avoiding higher premiums. When the leasing company’s modifier became less favorable due to accumulated losses, the employer would switch to another leasing company or restructure ownership to reset the modifier. This practice, along with more blatant forms of fraud, such as payroll misclassification, was rampant until stricter regulations were enforced.

Despite the closure of these loopholes, employee leasing, now known as Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs), remains popular, with approximately 700 firms operating in the United States and managing over 2 million leased employees. This continued popularity suggests that employers find value in the other benefits provided by leasing arrangements.

Benefits of Leasing

The main advantages of employee leasing for employers include reduced administrative costs, access to improved or more affordable employee benefits, and expert guidance on compliance with employment-related laws. These benefits allow businesses, especially small-to-medium-sized ones, to focus more on their core operations rather than on time-consuming administrative tasks.

Reduced Administrative Costs: Employers appreciate leasing arrangements because they offload much of the administrative burden, such as staying current with employment laws, filing reports, and managing payroll taxes. Leasing companies typically handle these tasks efficiently, often making tax deposits more frequently than required, which benefits both employers and the government.

Employee Benefits: Leasing companies leverage their large employee pools to obtain better rates on employee benefits. This allows small businesses to offer more competitive benefits packages, which can improve employee retention and morale.

Safety and Loss Control Services: Many leasing companies offer safety and loss control services, which help reduce workers compensation costs. By ensuring a safe work environment, leasing companies protect both their own interests and those of their clients.

Compliance with Employment-Related Laws: Leasing companies, as professional HR managers, ensure compliance with various employment-related laws, thereby reducing the risk of legal issues for their clients. This includes providing job descriptions, employee handbooks, and advice on issues like wrongful termination and discrimination.

Choosing a Leasing Company

The success of an employee leasing arrangement heavily depends on the leasing company chosen. Employers should carefully evaluate the financial stability, industry experience, and track record of potential leasing companies. It's also important to ensure that the leasing company is transparent about its services and fees and adheres to industry standards.

Financial Stability: Employers should verify the financial health of the leasing company and its insurance providers to ensure they meet their obligations.

Safety Programs: A sound safety program is crucial, especially since workers compensation insurance is a significant aspect of the leasing arrangement.

Reputation and Compliance: Membership in industry associations like the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations (NAPEO) or accreditation by the Employer Services Assurance Corporation can be indicators of a reputable leasing company.

Regulation of the Employee Leasing Industry

The employee leasing industry is regulated to protect the financial interests of clients and ensure leased employees are properly covered under workers compensation insurance. Many states require licensing or registration for leasing companies, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) has developed model regulations to prevent fraud and ensure that premiums reflect the actual risk.

Licensing Requirements: Approximately 75% of states require employee leasing companies to be licensed or registered, with specific provisions varying by state.

Workers Compensation Insurance: The placement of workers compensation insurance for leased employees can be complex, with regulations often requiring that coverage be secured in a way that reflects the actual risk. This is especially true in the residual market, where stricter controls are in place to prevent abuse.

General Liability Insurance

The Commercial General Liability (CGL) insurance policy has been revised to include leased employees in the definition of "employee," ensuring they are covered for liability arising from their employment. However, this also means that tort liability for injury to leased employees is excluded, potentially creating coverage gaps. Employers can address these gaps by attaching specific endorsements to their CGL policies or through contractual risk transfer agreements with the leasing company.

Conclusion

Employee leasing offers numerous benefits but also comes with risks that need to be carefully managed. By selecting a reputable leasing company and understanding the regulatory and insurance implications, employers can effectively leverage leasing arrangements to reduce costs and improve their operational efficiency.