Chapter 6: Rating Workers Compensation Risks
Overview
The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI), a consortium of insurance companies, plays a central role in compiling and distributing information on workers compensation rules, employee classifications, and advisory loss costs across most states. However, some states operate independently, maintaining their own manuals or monopolistic state funds for workers compensation. This chapter focuses on the NCCI’s Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability, a comprehensive guide containing rules, classifications, and underwriting guidelines for properly rating workers compensation insurance.
It's important to note that if you're working within a state that doesn’t follow NCCI guidelines, you should consult that state’s rating authority for the relevant rating methodologies.
Premium Calculation Overview
Workers compensation insurance premiums can be complex to compute, with methods varying across states. However, the core principles are consistent and worth understanding. Premiums are primarily based on three elements:
- Covered Payroll: The total remuneration paid to employees.
- Risk Classifications: Categories that represent the type of work employees perform.
- Experience Modifier: An adjustment based on the employer’s loss history.
The NCCI collects payroll and loss data for each risk classification, estimating the expected losses per $100 of payroll. Insurers then add their costs and desired profits to these loss costs to establish a rate for each classification. This rate is then multiplied by the exposure base (payroll divided by 100) to calculate the premium.
Key Components in Premium Calculation
Exposure Base:
- The primary exposure base for workers compensation insurance is payroll (NCCI Rule 2-A).
- Payroll includes wages, salaries, commissions, bonuses, and paid time off, among other forms of remuneration. Special rules apply to overtime pay, executive officers, partners, and sole proprietors (NCCI Rule 2-C and 2-E).
Classification:
- Classifications categorize businesses based on common risk exposures (NCCI Rule 1-A). Each business is assigned a classification that covers its primary operations rather than individual job roles within the business.
- Determining the correct classification is critical as it affects the rate applied to the payroll.
Experience Modifier:
- Experience rating adjusts premiums based on an employer’s loss history compared to the industry average. A modifier of 1.0 reflects average loss experience. Modifiers above or below 1.0 increase or decrease the premium, respectively.
- This modifier is applied to the unmodified premium to determine the final premium.
Loss Constant:
- A loss constant is an additional charge applied when the modified premium is below a certain threshold. Currently, Massachusetts is the only state applying this charge.
Expense Constant:
- The expense constant (NCCI Rule 3A-11) covers administrative costs like policy issuance and record-keeping. It is the same for all classifications within a state and is found in the state’s rate pages.
Minimum Premium:
- The minimum premium is the lowest amount charged for issuing a workers compensation policy (NCCI Rule 3A-16). If the calculated premium is below the state’s minimum, the minimum premium is charged instead.
Premium Discount:
- Premium discounts acknowledge that the administrative costs of servicing a policy don’t increase proportionally with the premium size. Larger premiums thus qualify for discounts.
- States applying a discount to policies use tables published in the NCCI Basic Manual.
Schedule Rating:
- Some states allow schedule rating, which adjusts the premium based on risk characteristics not captured in the experience modifier, such as safety programs or the condition of the premises.
Numerical Example
Let’s walk through a sample calculation to illustrate how an estimated annual premium is calculated:
Example:
ABC Plumbers, Inc. located in Chicago, IL, performs all types of plumbing work except for automatic sprinkler installation. The company has a total covered payroll of $730,000 and an experience modifier of 1.10.
1. Determine Classification:
- Classification code for "Plumbing NOC & Drivers" is 5183.
2. Find the Appropriate Rate:
- The rate for code 5183 in Illinois is $8.61.
3. Calculate the Unmodified Premium:
- Unmodified Premium = (Payroll ÷ 100) × Rate
- Unmodified Premium = ($730,000 ÷ 100) × $8.61 = $62,853
4. Apply the Experience Modifier:
- Modified Premium = Unmodified Premium × Experience Modifier
- Modified Premium = $62,853 × 1.10 = $69,139
5. Apply Premium Discount:
- Using the applicable NCCI table, ABC qualifies for a 7.8% discount.
- Discounted Premium = $69,139 - ($69,139 × 0.078) = $63,746
6. Add Expense Constant:
- The expense constant in Illinois is $280.
- Preliminary Estimated Annual Premium = $63,746 + $280 = $64,026
7. Compare to Minimum Premium:
- The minimum premium in Illinois for code 5183 is $1,000.
- Since the calculated premium exceeds this amount, the final estimated annual premium is $64,026.
Conclusion
Workers compensation insurance premium calculations are intricate and vary by state. Underwriters, agents, and brokers need a thorough understanding of classification procedures and rating processes to ensure accurate and fair premium assessments. Reference materials such as the NCCI Basic Manual are essential tools for determining the correct premium basis, classification, and other relevant factors.
