Understanding Different Types of Insurance Carriers

Admitted, Surplus Lines, and Risk Retention Groups

When purchasing insurance, most clients don’t consider the type of insurance carrier they are buying from. However, for agents and brokers, it’s critical to understand the differences between admitted carriers, surplus lines carriers, and risk retention groups. Each type of carrier has distinct regulatory obligations, benefits, and limitations, which affect the policies they offer and when they should be recommended to clients.

Admitted Insurance Carriers

Admitted insurance carriers are companies that have been licensed by the state insurance department to operate within that state. These carriers must comply with strict state regulations and are subject to oversight by the state insurance commissioner. As a result, policies issued by admitted carriers must adhere to state laws, including rate approvals, policy forms, and claims handling standards.

Key Benefits of Admitted Carriers:

- State Guarantee Fund Protection: One of the biggest advantages of admitted carriers is that if the company becomes insolvent, the state's guarantee fund may protect policyholders by covering unpaid claims.

- Regulatory Oversight: Admitted carriers must file their rates and policy forms with the state, ensuring transparency and compliance with state insurance laws.

- Consumer Protections: Since admitted carriers follow strict state regulations, policyholders may benefit from consumer protections, such as the ability to appeal denied claims through the state's insurance department.

 

Surplus Lines (Non-Admitted) Insurance Carriers

Surplus lines carriers, also known as non-admitted carriers, are insurance companies that are not licensed by the state in which they operate. Instead, they are regulated in their home state or country but are authorized to sell policies in other states under specific conditions. These carriers do not have to follow the same rate and form regulations as admitted carriers, giving them more flexibility to insure high-risk or unusual risks that admitted carriers may decline to cover.

When Is It Appropriate to Use Surplus Lines Carriers?

- Unusual or High-Risk Situations: Surplus lines carriers specialize in insuring risks that are too complex or risky for the admitted market. Examples include high-value homes, entertainment venues, professional athletes, and hazardous industries like oil and gas.

- Hard Market Conditions: During hard market cycles, admitted carriers may restrict the amount of coverage they offer or withdraw from certain markets entirely. In these situations, surplus lines carriers can fill the gap by providing coverage when standard carriers will not.

- Unique Coverage Needs: Some clients may have unique coverage requirements that cannot be addressed by admitted carriers. For instance, surplus lines carriers are often used for specialty liability coverages, such as pollution liability, professional liability for niche industries, or cyber insurance.

Important Considerations:

- No Guarantee Fund Protection: Unlike admitted carriers, surplus lines carriers are not backed by state guarantee funds. If a surplus lines carrier becomes insolvent, policyholders may not have recourse to recover unpaid claims.

- Higher Risk Tolerance: Because surplus lines carriers are willing to take on more risk, they often charge higher premiums than admitted carriers. Policyholders should be made aware of this trade-off when considering coverage through a surplus lines company.

Risk Retention Groups (RRGs)

Risk Retention Groups (RRGs) are a unique type of insurance entity formed under the federal Liability Risk Retention Act of 1986. They are owned by their members, who are typically businesses or professionals from the same industry that band together to form a self-insurance group. RRGs primarily provide liability coverage for their members, and they are only regulated by the state in which they are domiciled, though they can operate across state lines.

When Is It Appropriate to Use an RRG?

- No Other Options: As a rule of thumb, Risk Retention Groups should be used only as a last resort.

- Liability-Focused Needs: RRGs are ideal for liability coverage, particularly in industries where obtaining affordable or sufficient coverage through traditional carriers is difficult. Common RRG participants include healthcare providers (medical malpractice insurance), trucking companies (commercial auto liability), and manufacturers (product liability).

- Homogeneous Groups with Similar Risks: RRGs work best for groups of businesses or professionals with similar liability exposures. By pooling their resources, these groups can gain more control over their insurance costs and claims handling.

- Filling Gaps in the Market: Like surplus lines carriers, RRGs often step in when admitted markets are unwilling to offer liability coverage or when premiums in the traditional market become unaffordable.

Important Considerations:

- Limited Coverage Scope: RRGs are only allowed to write liability insurance, so they are not an option for property, workers' compensation, or other types of insurance needs.

- Solvency Risk: As member-owned entities, RRGs may face solvency challenges, especially if their claims experience is worse than expected. It’s important for agents and brokers to review the financial strength of an RRG before recommending it to clients.

- Regulatory Oversight: Unlike traditional insurance companies, RRGs are only subject to the regulations of their domicile state. While this offers some operational flexibility, it also means there may be fewer consumer protections in place compared to traditional carriers.

When Should a Retail Agent or Broker Sell a Policy Through a Surplus Lines Carrier or RRG?

  1. When the Risk Is Uninsurable by Admitted Markets:

If an admitted carrier declines a client’s risk due to its unusual nature, size, or complexity, the next logical step is to seek coverage through a surplus lines carrier. Similarly, if liability coverage is difficult to obtain for a homogeneous group of businesses, an RRG may be an appropriate solution.

 

  1. When Specialized Coverage Is Needed:

Some risks, such as environmental liability or cyber liability, may require specialized coverage that only surplus lines carriers or RRGs can offer. In these cases, going outside the admitted market may provide the client with the best protection.

 

  1. During a Hard Market:

During periods of reduced capacity in the insurance market (e.g., after significant natural disasters), admitted carriers may withdraw from certain markets or increase premiums to unaffordable levels. In such cases, surplus lines carriers can offer the necessary coverage, though often at a higher cost.

 

  1. When Flexibility Is Required:

Non-admitted carriers and RRGs can often craft more flexible policy terms than admitted carriers, particularly for unique risks. If a client requires customized coverage that cannot be found in the admitted market, it may be appropriate to seek a policy through these alternative carriers.

Best Practices When Selling Policies Outside the Admitted Market

  1. Fully Understand the Client’s Needs:

Before recommending a surplus lines carrier or RRG, thoroughly assess the client’s risks and ensure that the unique coverage needs cannot be met by an admitted carrier. This reduces E&O exposure and ensures the client is getting the right coverage.

 

  1. Disclose Non-Admitted Status:

Agents and brokers must clearly inform clients when they are purchasing a policy from a surplus lines carrier or RRG. Clients should understand that non-admitted carriers are not backed by state guarantee funds, and this higher risk should be communicated in writing.

 

  1. Verify Financial Strength:

Non-admitted carriers and RRGs are not subject to the same regulatory oversight as admitted companies, so it is crucial to verify their financial stability. Use reputable rating agencies, such as A.M. Best or Standard & Poor’s, to check the carrier’s solvency and claims-paying ability.

 

  1. Document Client Communication:

Properly document all client communications, including the explanation of risks, coverage exclusions, and the reason for placing the policy with a non-admitted carrier or RRG. Having a clear paper trail can protect the agent or broker from E&O claims if a dispute arises.

 

  1. Use Licensed Surplus Lines Brokers:

In many states, retail agents must go through a licensed surplus lines broker to access non-admitted carriers. Make sure to follow all state regulations and use an approved intermediary when placing coverage in the surplus lines market.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between admitted carriers, surplus lines carriers, and risk retention groups is essential for insurance agents and brokers when recommending the right coverage to their clients. While admitted carriers offer the most regulatory protection, surplus lines carriers and RRGs play a critical role in covering high-risk or specialized exposures. By following best practices, agents and brokers can ensure they are providing the best possible coverage solutions while protecting themselves from E&O risks.