Cyber and Privacy Insurance Policy Structure

Insuring Agreements

When purchasing cyber and privacy policies, insureds have the option to select from various insuring agreements, depending on what is offered by the insurer. There are 13 common insuring agreements typically found in cyber and privacy policy forms, categorized as follows:

13 Key Insuring Agreements

1.   First-Party/Post-Breach Response Coverage:

•   Privacy notification and crisis management expense

2.   Third-Party/Liability Coverages:

•   Information security and privacy liability

•   Regulatory defense and penalties

•   Payment card industry fines and assessments

•   Website media liability

•   Bodily injury (BI) and property damage (PD) liability

3.   First-Party/Time-Element Coverages:

•   Business interruption

•   Extra expense

4.   First-Party/Direct Property Loss Coverages:

•   Data assets

•   Cyber extortion

•   Computer fraud

•   Funds transfer fraud

•   Social engineering coverage

However, it’s important to note that most cyber and privacy policies in the current market do not include all 13 agreements. There are two primary reasons for this:

1.   Combination of Agreements: Insurers often combine two or more of these insuring agreements into a single coverage option.

2.   Limited Offerings: Not all insurers provide every type of coverage available in these insuring agreements.

As a result, most cyber and privacy policies contain between 7 and 10 insuring agreements. Given this variability, it is crucial to carefully review policies, paying attention to similar coverage with different terminology, combined agreements, and split agreements. Additionally, identifying other types of policies that offer similar coverage is essential to ensure comprehensive protection and to avoid coverage overlaps or gaps.

First-Party/Post-Breach Response Insuring Agreements

Most cyber and privacy policies include an insuring agreement covering the immediate costs of responding to a data breach. This is typically referred to as “privacy notification and crisis management” coverage.

Privacy Notification and Crisis Management: This insuring agreement covers the direct expenses required for a rapid and effective response to a data breach. Acting as the “loss containment” component of a cyber and privacy policy, this coverage aims to minimize the ultimate costs of a breach by facilitating a swift and effective response. It typically includes costs related to:

  • Hiring computer forensics experts for breach remediation.
  • Engaging a public relations firm to manage communication about the breach.
  • Providing a post-breach call center for affected customers.
  • Notifying affected individuals and organizations.
  • Offering credit monitoring and identity theft monitoring services.
  • Notifying banks and credit card companies.

A significant benefit of this coverage is the access it provides to expert assistance, often referred to as “breach coaching,” which is invaluable in a crisis.

In its 2018 Cost of a Data Breach Study, the Ponemon Institute reported that the average cost of responding to a data breach was $3.86 million. Given these high costs, having insurance that covers privacy notification and crisis management expenses is crucial.

Where Else Is First-Party Coverage Available?

Generally, other types of insurance policies do not cover privacy notification and crisis management services following a data breach. However, the AIG CyberEdge form and similar policies from AEGIS, CFC, and Coalition do provide such coverage.

The best strategy for coordinating coverage is to ensure that the privacy notification and crisis management insuring agreement within your standard cyber and privacy policy functions as primary coverage, with any additional policies acting as excess coverage.

Third-Party Liability Insuring Agreements

Cyber and privacy policies may also include third-party liability coverages, such as:

•  Information Security and Privacy Liability

•  Regulatory Defense and Penalties

•  Payment Card Industry Fines and Assessments

•  Website Media Liability

•  Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability

These agreements cover a wide range of liabilities related to data breaches and other cyber incidents.

For example, the Information Security and Privacy Liability agreement covers damages resulting from unauthorized disclosure of personal information, denial of service attacks, and transmission of malicious code, among other exposures.

Where Else Is Third-Party Coverage Available?

Coverage for these liabilities may also be found in other types of policies, such as fiduciary liability (FL) policies and employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) policies, depending on the specific exposure. To ensure comprehensive protection, it’s advisable to coordinate coverage between your cyber and privacy policies and these other policies, making the cyber and privacy policy primary.

Summary

When structuring an insurance program, it’s essential to consider both the specific insuring agreements available under cyber and privacy policies and the coverage available under other types of policies. By carefully coordinating coverage, you can ensure that your organization is fully protected against the wide range of risks associated with cyber activities.