Writing Quality Business and Protecting our E&O

Letter from the President:

Write quality business, it's required to be successful in the long term for all parties concerned.
What is quality business? Let’s look at it from the perspective of the client, the agency, and the carrier.
Through the lens of the client, quality business is actually obtaining the coverage they think they are buying. They want no surprises when a loss occurs. Does your sales process include documentation that shows you and the client are on the same page?
The agency's survival depends on quality business. Writing policies that accurately represent the client's business will protect our loss ratios. Carriers price the policies based on the risk they believe they are taking on. When unexpected claims hit that was not priced into the policy, loss ratios go up. If loss ratios go up the agency is at risk of losing carrier appointments. Writing quality business also means having the documentation to prove you discussed recommendations of coverage that is not purchased, especially if the coverage is customarily purchased. THIS PROTECTS OUR E&O INSURANCE. If we as an agency have too many E&O claims, we will not be able to obtain our insurance through the preferred carriers. Our rates could double or triple or worse. It’s currently our 3rd largest expense behind payroll and our AMS. So, when we announce new compliance guidelines for documentation, we will require100% adherence.
Carriers define quality business using a metric of the combined ratio. The combined ratio includes the loss ratio and the cost of doing business. The loss ratio includes future expected losses. It’s called IBNR (incurred but not reported). They reserve a dollar amount for the future on a claim that has happened, but the final payout is still unknown based on an expected future settlement. Liability and WC claims tend to have a longer tail than let’s say commercial auto.
The cost of doing business is added to the loss ratio. There will be a number that is acceptable to the carrier. A 100% combined ratio means the carrier broke even. They are happy with a mid-90% number. When they look at our agency the cost of doing business with us may be higher or lower than other agencies. One metric that they look at is our quote to bind ratios. Do they have to work harder on our accounts to get a bind? Some of our producers sell a large percentage of their quotes others not so much. We have producers that get quotes and never even write an account with the carrier. That hurts all of us.
I’m writing this letter to all of you so that you better understand the business we’re in. While this is certainly not an exhaustive discussion on the subject, it should give you a good idea of a few of the points to consider. It’s not just marketing and sales. Make it easy for me to tell carriers that as a group O&A is not only a top producer but a profitable relationship for them as well.
As we are getting ready to go into a massive growth period, let’s all write quality business. It is the only way to long-term success!

Steve