Handling an Insurance Audit

Introduction:

An audit is an essential part of the insurance process, ensuring that the premium charged accurately reflects the insured's risk exposure based on the final rating basis (e.g., gross sales, payroll, sub-out costs, etc.). It’s crucial for agents to understand the audit process to guide clients and prevent unnecessary financial consequences. 

1. Understanding the Audit Process

- Purpose of the Audit: The audit verifies the actual figures used for the policy's rating basis, such as gross sales, payroll, or sub-out costs, to determine the correct premium. 

- Documentation Requirements: Insurance carriers may request tax documents, profit and loss statements, or other records to verify these figures. 

- Timeframe: Carriers have up to 3 years from the policy expiration date to conduct an audit. 

2. Handling Common Challenges with Insureds

Insureds Unaware of Audit Requirements:  

  - Some clients might be unaware that they could be audited, despite it being disclosed in the policy and proposal. 

  - Agents should remind clients that audits are a standard practice and refer them to where this information was disclosed. 

   

Consequences of Not Completing an Audit: 

  - The carrier will estimate the rating basis and could charge a significant surcharge, sometimes up to 300% of the original premium. 

  - Failure to complete the audit can also result in policy cancellation, even if the insured is with a different carrier through an assigned risk pool. 

 

Agent Action: Always contact clients nearing their audit deadline to encourage completion. Highlight the potential consequences, but maintain a supportive and friendly tone. 

3. Assisting Clients After the Audit Deadline

If the Insured Misses the Deadline: 

  - The client might receive an estimated invoice, but they can still complete the audit and have the invoice adjusted. 

  - Agents should reassure clients that submitting the audit afterward can correct their premium. 

 

Agent Action: Encourage the client to complete the audit even if the deadline has passed and assist them with any questions or concerns they have. 

4. Phone-Based Audits

Convenience and Accuracy: 

  - Some audits are conducted over the phone, where an auditor asks the insured questions to determine any additional premium. 

  - This method can sometimes lead to inaccurate adjustments if the insured isn’t fully prepared or provides incorrect information. 

 

Agent Action: Remind clients to have accurate records on hand during phone audits. If discrepancies arise, inform them they can dispute the audit by providing documentation with the correct numbers. 

5. Handling Disputes and Incorrect Invoices

Disputing an Audit: 

  - If the insured receives an invoice that doesn’t seem accurate, they have the right to dispute it. 

  - Supporting documentation, such as financial records, can be submitted to correct any inaccuracies. 

 

Agent Action: Guide clients through the dispute process, ensuring they understand what documentation is required to support their case. 

6. Addressing Additional Premium Invoices

Paying the Additional Premium:  

  - If an audit results in additional premium charges, it is crucial that the insured pays this amount promptly. 

  - Failure to pay can lead to collection activity and even the cancellation of their current policy. 

 

Agent Action: Encourage clients to pay any additional premiums as soon as possible to avoid disruptions in their coverage. 

Best Practices for Agents:

  1. Proactive Communication: Regularly remind clients about the importance of completing audits and the consequences of failing to do so.
  2. Offer Assistance: Help clients gather the necessary documents or prepare them for a phone audit to ensure accurate results.
  3. Educate on Potential Outcomes: Clearly explain how estimates, surcharges, and possible policy cancellations work if the audit is not completed.
  4. Be a Resource: Act as a supportive resource for your clients throughout the audit process, making them feel confident and informed.

Additional Tips:

- Consider providing clients with a checklist of documents they might need for the audit. 

- If the insured is struggling to complete the audit, offer to assist with the process or liaise with the carrier on their behalf.