Chapter 10: Valuation, Coinsurance, Limits, and Waiting Period for Business Income

This chapter covers the essential provisions in business income coverage that determine the payout in the event of a covered loss, including:

- Valuation (actual loss sustained)

- Coinsurance

- Limits of insurance

- Business income waiting period

Determining Business Income Loss

Business income coverage is based on the “actual loss sustained,” meaning the insurer pays the true loss amount rather than a preset figure. The loss amount is calculated considering:

- The business’s net income before the loss

- The projected net income if the loss hadn’t occurred

- Necessary expenses to resume operations

- Other relevant information

Disputes may arise over what the business's net income would have been or which expenses are necessary to restore operations.

Calculating Extra Expense Loss

For policies that include extra expense coverage (CP 00 30), extra expenses are calculated based on:

- Costs exceeding normal operations

- Salvage value of temporarily purchased property

- Expenses that reduce business income loss

Resumption of Operations

While businesses aren’t required to resume operations quickly or at all, the policy bases recovery on the reasonable time it should take to resume operations. If the insured delays or chooses not to resume operations, they only recover the amount they would have earned during the reasonable restoration period.

Business Income Coinsurance

The business income coverage forms include a coinsurance clause, requiring the insured to purchase coverage equal to a specific percentage of projected business income over a 12-month period. Failure to meet this requirement results in a coinsurance penalty, reducing the loss recovery based on the ratio of actual insurance to required insurance.

For example, if a business with a $100,000 coverage limit suffers a $50,000 loss but should have had a $125,000 limit under a 50% coinsurance clause, the recovery is reduced to $40,000.

Agreed Value Coverage Option

Forecasting future business results can be challenging, and underestimating can lead to a coinsurance penalty. The agreed value coverage option suspends the coinsurance clause for 12 months, provided the insurer and insured agree on a set value beforehand. This option requires submitting a Business Income Report/Worksheet (CP 15 15) to determine an accurate agreed value.

Business Income Premium Adjustment Endorsement

The Business Income Premium Adjustment (CP 15 20) endorsement adjusts the premium based on actual business income results at the end of the policy year, helping avoid coinsurance penalties while allowing flexibility in selecting coverage limits.

Limits of Insurance

The business income coverage limit is the maximum payout for a single occurrence, with two exceptions:

- $100,000 for newly acquired locations

- $2,500 for interruption of computer operations

The extra expense coverage is included within this limit.

Choosing Business Income Limits

Selecting the right business income limit involves considering:

- Estimated Business Income: Start with projected income for the policy period, using the Business Income Report/Worksheet (CP 15 15).

- Estimated Time to Repair: Consider the time needed to repair or replace the damaged property and resume operations, accounting for any delays in receiving custom machinery or other materials.

- Coinsurance Compliance: Ensure the selected limit meets coinsurance requirements, typically based on the projected worst-case recovery time.

- Extended Period of Indemnity: Account for additional time after repairs are complete, particularly if the insured opts for the extended period of indemnity.

- Extra Expenses: Factor in extra expenses that may arise during recovery, ensuring the selected limit covers both business income and extra expenses.

Scheduled vs. Blanket Limits

Scheduled limits apply to specific locations, while blanket limits cover multiple locations or categories of property. Blanket limits are generally recommended because they offer better protection against underinsurance and coinsurance penalties.

- Scheduled Limits: Calculate limits based on projected income for each location.

- Blanket Limits: Combine projected income across locations and adjust for coinsurance requirements.

Special Considerations

- Interdependent Locations: Treat interdependent locations as a single unit when selecting limits, or use a blanket limit.

- Seasonal Variation: Adjust limits to account for seasonal income fluctuations, especially during peak periods.

Business Income Waiting Period

While there is no traditional deductible, business income coverage includes a 72-hour waiting period after the loss before coverage begins. This waiting period can be shortened or removed using the Business Income Changes—Beginning of the Period of Restoration (CP 15 56) endorsement.

This streamlined approach helps ensure businesses are adequately covered and avoid penalties, while also allowing for flexibility based on individual needs and circumstances.