Chapter 6: Valuation, Coinsurance, Limits, and Deductible
This chapter covers the key elements that determine how much an insured will recover when covered property is damaged. These elements include:
- Valuation of covered property
- Coinsurance and the agreed value option
- Limits of insurance
- Deductible
Valuation of Covered Property
The valuation provision typically values covered property at its actual cash value (ACV), though a replacement cost option can be selected. ACV is not defined in the policy, but courts generally define it in one of three ways:
- Replacement cost minus depreciation
- Fair market value
- Broad evidence rule (considering all relevant evidence)
Exceptions to ACV include tenants’ improvements, glass, stock sold but not delivered, and minor building repairs ($2,500 or less).
Replacement Cost Option: If elected, the insurer pays the lesser of the cost to replace with comparable materials, the amount actually spent on repairs, or the policy limit. This option applies only if repairs are made within a reasonable time, otherwise, the payment defaults to ACV.
Valuation Endorsements modify the valuation terms, such as the Manufacturer’s Selling Price Finished Stock Only (CP 99 30) or the Functional Building Valuation (CP 04 38).
Coinsurance
Coinsurance requires the insured to carry insurance equal to a specified percentage of the property’s value, usually 80-90%. If underinsured, the insured shares in the loss—this is known as a coinsurance penalty.
Example: A building valued at $1 million with a 90% coinsurance clause should be insured for at least $900,000. If only $800,000 is insured and a $100,000 loss occurs, the insured would only recover $88,389 after applying the formula:
(Amount of loss x Amount Carried / Amount Required) – Deductible = Loss Recovery
Agreed Value Option: This suspends the coinsurance requirement if the insurer agrees that the insured’s stated property values are sufficient. This option eliminates the risk of a coinsurance penalty but must be renewed annually with updated values.
Limits of Insurance
The limits of insurance determine the maximum payout for a loss. These can be scheduled limits (specific to each location or type of property) or blanket limits (covering multiple locations or types). Blanket limits offer flexibility and reduce the risk of underinsurance, especially when combined with the agreed value option.
Example: A business with two buildings valued at $2 million each and contents valued at $1 million each can insure with specific limits (e.g., $2 million per building) or a blanket limit (e.g., $6 million total). Blanket limits can protect against underinsurance in case of total loss at one location.
Dealing with Property Value Fluctuations: For businesses with fluctuating values, options like the Inflation Guard, Peak Season Endorsement, and Value Reporting Endorsement help maintain appropriate coverage. These tools adjust limits to account for inflation, seasonal inventory spikes, or other fluctuations, ensuring adequate coverage throughout the policy term.
Deductible
The deductible is subtracted from the loss amount, with the insurer paying the remainder up to the policy limit. The deductible applies per occurrence, and its application doesn’t always reduce the insured’s recovery if the loss exceeds the limit plus the deductible.
Example: If a $100,000 building is insured for $90,000 with a $5,000 deductible and a total loss occurs, the insured collects the full $90,000 limit, as the loss exceeds the deductible plus the limit.
In summary, understanding how valuation, coinsurance, limits, and deductibles interact is crucial to ensuring adequate recovery after a loss, minimizing out-of-pocket expenses, and avoiding penalties.
