Chapter 9: Workers Compensation Deductible Plans
Overview
Workers compensation deductible plans have become a prevalent method for employers to manage insurance costs, often surpassing the use of retrospective rating plans. Deductible plans, whether small or large, offer potential savings on premiums, helping employers control their workers compensation expenses.
Small deductible plans are standardized and available in states that have approved them, while large deductible plans are more customized and are filed individually by insurers. These large deductible plans are typically available to employers who meet specific financial criteria, providing an alternative to retrospective rating or self-insurance.
Small Deductible Plans
Workers compensation deductibles, though less common than liability deductibles, are available in most states. State-specific rules and regulations, available through individual state insurance departments or the NCCI, govern these plans, which may apply to medical-only, indemnity-only, or both types of claims.
In a small deductible plan, the insurer pays the full amount of each claim upfront and then seeks reimbursement from the insured for the deductible portion, typically through monthly or quarterly billing. The terms of this arrangement are specified in an endorsement attached to the policy. Premium reductions for implementing a deductible vary by state, ranging from 0.2% to 51%, depending on the size of the deductible. State-specific rules also determine how these deductions impact the insured’s experience modifier and how losses are reported.
Large Deductible Programs
Large deductible plans provide a viable risk financing alternative for many employers, offering benefits similar to retrospective rating plans without some of their drawbacks. These plans are especially attractive to employers considering self-insurance.
A large deductible is essentially the first layer of loss funding, with the insurer handling only the portion of losses exceeding the deductible. For example, if an employer’s standard premium is $1 million, with 65% representing expected losses, a $250,000 per-claim deductible could significantly reduce the insurer's portion of the expected loss amount. The reduction depends on the insured’s risk profile and loss forecast, which helps estimate the effect of the deductible.
In a large deductible plan, the insurer typically bills the insured in installments throughout the policy term, covering loss adjustment expenses and non-loss-related expenses. Fixed payments allow the insured to better manage cash flow. However, some plans require a larger upfront payment or the establishment of a loss fund, replenished as needed. Whether defense costs are included in the deductible varies by insurer, which can impact the overall cost-effectiveness of the plan.
How Large Deductible Plans Work
Large deductible plans offer flexibility in how payments are structured, which can benefit employers with stable or predictable losses. Insurers may allow for fixed periodic payments based on projected losses, with adjustments made after the coverage term if actual losses differ. Alternatively, some plans require a larger upfront payment and ongoing replenishment of a loss fund, providing immediate cash flow benefits if losses are low.
Insurers may include defense costs within the deductible, which could exhaust the deductible more quickly, depending on the claims history. This inclusion can be beneficial if the deductible is relatively low and the claims are large, as it allows quicker access to the insurer’s funds.
Large deductible plans do not have a predetermined closure date, which can create uncertainty regarding future costs. However, insurers may offer buyout options to close out open claims, transferring the liability to another insurer if necessary. Security is often required to collateralize expected losses within the deductible, typically in the form of a letter of credit, which remains in place until all claims are settled.
Insurer Filing Requirements
States with large deductible programs provide general guidelines for insurer submissions, including minimum premium and deductible levels. Insurers must file their plans with state authorities for approval before offering them to employers.
Growth in Popularity
Large deductible plans have gained popularity due to their ability to reduce fixed premium costs without the administrative burden of self-insurance. They also benefit insurers by reducing exposure to high-frequency losses and improving their premium-to-surplus ratios, allowing them to underwrite more business. The requirement for collateral in these plans also provides insurers with added security against adverse loss developments.
While large deductible plans offer significant advantages, including cash flow benefits and reduced upfront premium costs, they do not significantly reduce the ultimate potential costs of workers compensation claims. The insured remains responsible for paying losses within the deductible, which can incentivize better loss control and safety practices.
Disadvantages of Large Deductible Plans
The primary disadvantage of large deductible plans is the risk of large, aggregated losses. Deductibles usually apply per event, regardless of the number of employees injured, meaning the deductible applies once to the total loss. Without an aggregate deductible, the insured’s out-of-pocket costs could be unlimited. Additionally, the inclusion of defense costs within the deductible can be a disadvantage, depending on the claims history.
Some states have introduced loss-based assessments on large deductible plans to make up for lost tax revenue, which can significantly impact the ultimate cost of the program. These assessments are calculated as a percentage of the insured’s losses in each state where claims are filed.
In summary, large deductible plans offer an effective way to manage workers compensation costs, particularly for larger employers. However, they come with risks that need to be carefully managed, particularly in terms of potential large losses and ongoing financial obligations.
