Chapter 8: Retrospective Rating Plans
Overview
For some employers, predictability in insurance costs is crucial. However, others are willing to accept a degree of uncertainty if it could lead to reduced long-term costs. Loss-sensitive insurance plans offer such opportunities by tying premiums directly to the employer's actual loss experience during the coverage period. While these plans come with inherent risks, particularly because actual costs will reflect the actual losses incurred, they also offer potential rewards for employers committed to strong safety and loss control measures.
Loss-sensitive plans, including retrospective rating plans, are typically not suitable for small employers due to the higher administrative costs and the potential for significant fluctuations in premiums. For larger employers with a broader spread of risk, these plans can offer a viable alternative. Retrospective rating plans allow for adjustments to the premium based on the actual losses during the policy period, providing a more immediate reflection of an employer’s loss control efforts compared to other methods.
However, for some employers, especially those with poor safety records, the only available coverage option might be a loss-sensitive plan, as insurers look to mitigate their risk.
Types of Retrospective Rating Plans
Retrospective rating plans are primarily used in workers compensation, employers liability, general liability, auto liability, and auto physical damage insurance. They can also be extended to other lines of insurance. The basic concept behind these plans is to adjust the premium based on the actual incurred or paid losses during the policy period.
1. Incurred Loss Retros: These plans calculate the premium based on the losses incurred during the policy period. This system allows employers to influence their insurance costs more directly by managing their loss experience. Key features include:
Basic Premium: Covers insurer expenses, profit, and contingencies but excludes taxes and certain loss adjustment expenses.
Converted Losses: Incurred losses multiplied by a Loss Conversion Factor (LCF), which accounts for unallocated claims expenses.
Excess Loss Premium: Optional and applies when the employer opts to cap individual losses to reduce the impact of large claims.
Retro Development Premium: An optional factor that anticipates future loss increases, stabilizing premium adjustments over time.
2. Paid Loss Retros: These plans are similar to incurred loss retros but differ in two key ways:
- The insured pays only the expense portion of the premium during the policy year, retaining the majority for loss payments as they occur, offering significant cash flow advantages.
- Premiums are built using expense and loss components rather than a standard formula of rate times payroll.
Adjusting Retrospective Premiums
Retrospective adjustments are made post-policy expiration, typically 18 to 22 months after inception. These adjustments continue annually until all claims are resolved or both parties agree to cease adjustments. Incurred loss retros reflect adjustments based on losses to date, whereas paid loss retros adjust based on the actual paid losses and the remaining expense payments.
Three-Year vs. One-Year Plans
Employers can choose between a 1-year and a 3-year retrospective plan. A 3-year plan generally stabilizes premium fluctuations and offers more credibility, often resulting in lower basic and maximum premium factors. However, an extremely adverse year can offset the benefits of good years, leading some employers to prefer a 1-year plan for greater flexibility.
Cancellation Procedures
Cancellation procedures vary depending on which party requests cancellation. If the insurer cancels, the premium is prorated, and retrospective calculations apply to the earned premium. Insured-initiated cancellations, particularly mid-term, can incur significant penalties, especially in a 3-year plan. This discourages early cancellation, as the employer may forfeit any retrospective return premiums due to favorable loss experience.
Large Risk Alternative Rating Option
For employers with significant premiums (usually $1 million or more), a large risk alternative rating option is available. This allows the insured and insurer to agree on a customized plan, potentially involving paid loss retros, unbundled services, and bespoke pricing based on the insured’s own experience and the insurer’s expense needs.
In summary, retrospective rating plans offer a dynamic way to align insurance premiums with actual loss experience, providing an incentive for employers to manage their risks effectively. These plans require careful consideration, particularly for smaller employers, due to the inherent risks and administrative costs involved. However, for larger organizations, these plans can offer significant long-term cost savings and improved cash flow.
