Chapter 7: Workers Compensation Guaranteed Cost Programs
Overview
Guaranteed cost insurance is one of the most widely used rating plans for workers compensation insurance, particularly for employers with relatively small premiums. This type of insurance is prospective, meaning the premium is determined based on anticipated losses rather than actual losses during the policy period. The final premium is adjusted only for differences between estimated and actual payroll (exposure) and for any midterm rate changes applicable to policies already in force.
For the purposes of this discussion, "guaranteed cost insurance" refers to any insurance policy where the premium for the current period is unaffected by the insured's loss experience during that period. However, the premium may be influenced by prior loss experience, the loss experience of a class of insureds, or the insured retaining some part of individual losses.
This chapter covers the factors influencing the final and long-term costs of guaranteed cost workers compensation insurance, including experience rating, premium discounts, small deductibles, and dividend plans. Although current losses do not affect premiums during the policy period, they do impact future premiums through experience rating. Employers with higher-than-average losses will pay more for workers compensation insurance in subsequent years, while those with better-than-average loss histories will benefit from lower premiums.
Cost-Saving Options
Several cost-saving features and favorable cash flow plans are available with guaranteed cost workers compensation insurance. These include premium discounts, small deductibles, and dividend plans. While small deductibles and premium discounts are popular tools for reducing costs, dividend plans are less common today due to the emergence of more sophisticated risk financing options. However, dividend plans still appeal to smaller employers who may not qualify for significant discounts and are reluctant to take on the risks associated with deductibles.
Premium Discounts
In states that have not adopted a loss costs rating system, guaranteed cost workers compensation policies with a standard premium exceeding $5,000 may be eligible for a premium discount. These discounts are applied at graduated rates as the premium increases.
Small Deductibles
Small deductible plans have been approved in most states (except for monopolistic states), and many states have also approved large deductible plans. Under a small deductible plan, the employer assumes a deductible for each claim in exchange for a significant premium reduction. These plans are widely regarded as effective cost-control tools and are often used by employers to gauge their tolerance for risk.
In most states, insurers are required to offer small deductible plans where approved. The maximum deductibles range from $2,500 in many jurisdictions to as high as $75,000 in Florida. Most small deductible plans cover both medical and indemnity (lost-time) claims, with discounts ranging from less than 1% to more than 40%, depending on the deductible size and the insured’s hazard group.
Dividend Plans
Dividend plans offer a return of premium to the insured after the policy period ends, hence the term "participating" insurance plans. While these plans were more popular 20 to 30 years ago, they have seen a resurgence in certain markets due to the recent softening of the workers compensation market. There are two types of dividend plans:
1. Flat Dividend Plans - Under this plan, a fixed percentage of the final audited premium is returned to the insured, regardless of loss experience. However, insurers are selective about the insureds they subject to such plans. Dividends are typically calculated and paid out after the policy audit and must be declared by the insurer's board of directors and approved by the state insurance department.
2. Sliding Scale Dividend Plans - In these loss-sensitive plans, the dividend percentage varies based on the insured’s loss experience and premium size. The standard premium is calculated in the same way as in guaranteed cost programs, and the final dividend is determined based on the net loss ratio after policy expiration. As loss ratios increase, the dividend percentage decreases, and at higher loss ratios, dividends may not be paid at all.
Guaranteed cost workers compensation insurance offers a straightforward approach for employers, particularly those with smaller premiums. Although the premium is fixed for the policy period, factors like experience rating, small deductibles, and dividend plans can influence the overall cost of coverage. Understanding these components helps employers make informed decisions about their workers compensation insurance strategies.
