CGL Basics - Lesson 3
Coverage B Insuring Agreement
Just like in Coverage A, the CGL policy briefly explains what is covered in the Insuring Agreement and then goes on to list several exclusions to coverage.
The key parts oft he insuring agreement reads as follows:
“We will pay those sums that the insured becomes legally obligated to pay as damages because of "personal and advertising injury" to which this insurance applies...”
The question then becomes, what is a personal and advertising injury? The answer to this can be found in the policy’s Definitions section where it reads:
“‘Personal and advertising injury’ means injury, including consequential ‘bodily injury’, arising out of one or more of the following offenses:
a. False arrest, detention or imprisonment;
b. Malicious prosecution;
c. The wrongful eviction from, wrongful entry into, or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a room, dwelling or premises that a person occupies, committed by or on behalf of its owner, landlord, or lessor;
d. Oral or written publication, in any matter, of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or disparages a person's or organization's goods, products or services;
e. Oral or written publication, in any matter, of material that violates a person's right of privacy;
f. The use of another's advertising idea in your ‘advertisement’; or
g. Infringing upon another's copyright, trade dress, or slogan in your ‘advertisement’.”
To summarize what is covered in the insuring agreement, Coverage B of the Commercial General Liability (CGL) policy provides protection for "Personal and Advertising Injury Liability." This coverage insures against legal liabilities arising from specific non-physical harms, such as defamation (libel and slander), false arrest, wrongful eviction, violation of privacy rights, misappropriation of advertising ideas, and copyright infringement. It covers the insured's defense costs and any settlements or judgments related to these claims, provided the offenses occur in the course of the insured's business operations and within the policy period.
The second key part for the insuring agreement defines how coverage is triggered and reads as follows:
“This insurance applies to ‘personal and advertising injury’ caused by an offense arising out of your business but only if the offense was committed in the ‘coverage territory’ during the policy period.”
In order for coverage to be triggered, the offense must have taken place during the policy period and within the coverage territory.
Coverage B Exclusions
There are 16 exclusions to this coverage:
a) Knowing Violation Of Rights Of Another
b) Material Published With Knowledge Of Falsity
Exclusions A and B are very similar to exclusion A in Coverage A. Insurance is designed to cover the unforeseen, accidents. Intentionally violating someone’s rights or publishing false information will not be covered by general liability insurance.
c) Material Published Prior to Policy Period
The policy takes into account when the offensive material was “first published” in order to determine when coverage is triggered.
d) Criminals Acts
This policy does not coverage injury arising out of criminal acts.
e) Contractual Liability
Unlike in coverage A where there are certain types of contracts defined as “insured contracts”, the contractual liability exclusion the Coverage B is absolute. There is no coverage for any liability assumed in a contract for personal and advertising injury.
f) Breach of Contact
If the injury or damage occurs because the insured did not uphold their contractual obligations, this exclusion will prevent coverage under the policy. The rationale behind the breach of contract exclusion is that general liability policies are intended to cover tort-based claims (such as negligence, libel, slander) rather than contractual disputes. Breach of contract claims are often better suited to be addressed through other types of insurance, such as Professional Liability or Errors and Omissions (E&O) insurance, which are designed to cover professional service-related contractual issues.
g) Quality Of Performance Of Goods- Failure To Conform To Statements
If the insured makes claims about their product's or service's quality or performance, and the product or service fails to meet those claims, this exclusion would apply. The rationale behind this exclusion is that the CGL policy is intended to cover personal and advertising injury claims that arise from torts, such as defamation, invasion of privacy, or wrongful eviction, rather than contract-based disputes or business risks related to product performance. By excluding claims based on the failure of goods or services to meet advertised quality or performance, insurers limit their exposure to product liability and warranty claims, which are more appropriately covered under other types of insurance, such as Product Liability or Errors and Omissions (E&O) insurance.
h) Wrong Description Of Prices
If the insured makes claims about their product's or service's quality or performance, and the product or service fails to meet those claims, this exclusion would apply.
Excluded Scenario: A company advertises that its new software can increase a business's efficiency by 50%. A customer purchases the software based on this claim but finds that it only increases efficiency by 10%. The customer sues the company for misrepresentation, alleging that the software did not perform as promised. In this case, exclusion g would apply because the claim is based on the product failing to conform to the performance statements made in the advertisement. As a result, the CGL policy would not cover this claim.
i) Infringement Of Copyright Patent, Trademark or Trade Secret
This exclusion is designed to prevent coverage for personal and advertising injury claims that arise from the infringement of intellectual property rights.
Excluded Scenario: A technology company is sued for patent infringement because it is alleged to have used a patented technology in its products without authorization. The plaintiff claims damages for the unauthorized use of their patented invention. In this case, exclusion i would apply, and the CGL policy would not cover the claim for patent infringement.
The rationale behind this exclusion is to prevent the CGL policy from covering intellectual property disputes, which are often complex, expensive, and beyond the scope of standard liability insurance. Intellectual property rights are typically protected through specialized insurance policies, such as Intellectual Property Liability insurance, which are designed to handle the unique risks associated with IP infringement claims.
j) Insureds In Media And Internet Type Businesses
This exclusion is designed to exclude coverage for personal and advertising injury claims that arise from the activities of businesses specifically involved in media and internet-related services. This exclusion recognizes that these businesses have unique risks that are typically outside the scope of standard general liability coverage.
The types of businesses affected are advertising agencies, media companies, publishing houses, website design firms and internet service providers.
The rationale behind the "Insureds in Media and Internet Type Businesses" exclusion is that businesses in these fields face unique and heightened risks of personal and advertising injury claims due to the nature of their work. Because these risks are more significant and specialized than those faced by typical businesses, they require tailored insurance coverage. Media Liability insurance, Professional Liability insurance, or Errors and Omissions (E&O) insurance policies are better suited to address the specific exposures of media and internet-related businesses.
k) Electronic Chatrooms Or Bulletin Boards
The exclusion applies broadly to any personal and advertising injury claims associated with the content or activities in electronic chatrooms or bulletin boards that the insured owns, operates, or controls. This includes platforms hosted on the insured's website or any third-party site where the insured has administrative control.
Excluded Scenario: A company runs an online forum where users can discuss various topics. One user posts defamatory comments about a public figure, and the public figure sues the company for defamation. Because the defamatory statements were made in an electronic chatroom controlled by the company, this exclusion would apply, and the CGL policy would not cover the defamation claim.
The rationale behind the "Electronic Chatrooms or Bulletin Boards" exclusion is to limit the insurer's exposure to the significant and unique risks associated with user-generated content. Electronic forums can be breeding grounds for defamatory statements, invasions of privacy, and other harmful activities that are difficult to monitor and control. These risks are typically higher than those encountered in traditional business operations.
l) Unauthorized Use of Another’s Name or Product
The exclusion applies to any use of another’s name or product without permission, specifically in ways that suggest a misleading affiliation or endorsement. It targets deceptive practices often used to drive traffic or create confusion about the origin of goods or services, such as cybersquatting, meta tagging, and false endorsements.
Excluded Scenario: A small electronics retailer creates a website with a domain name that includes the trademarked name of a well-known electronics brand without authorization. The brand owner sues the retailer for trademark infringement and misleading advertising. Because the claim arises from the unauthorized use of another’s name in the domain name, this exclusion would apply, and the CGL policy would not cover the claim.
The rationale behind the "Unauthorized Use of Another’s Name or Product" exclusion is to limit the insurer’s exposure to risks associated with intellectual property disputes and misleading advertising practices. Unauthorized use of names, products, or identifying characteristics can lead to significant legal battles and financial liabilities, which are beyond the scope of standard general liability coverage.
m) Pollution
n) Pollution-related
As in Coverage A, pollution or pollution related claims are not covered. These types of losses should be insured by a Pollution Liability policy.
o) War
As in Coverage A, losses related to acts of war, are not covered.
p) Recording And Distribution Of Material Or Information In Violation Of Law
This exclusion applies to personal and advertising injury claims arising directly or indirectly out of any action or omission that violates or is alleged to violate:
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA): This law restricts telemarketing calls, auto-dialed calls, prerecorded calls, text messages, and unsolicited faxes.
- CAN-SPAM Act: This law sets rules for commercial email, establishes requirements for commercial messages, gives recipients the right to stop receiving emails, and spells out tough penalties for violations.
- Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA): This law regulates the collection, dissemination, and use of consumer information, including consumer credit information.
- Any Other Statute, Ordinance, or Regulation: This includes any federal, state, or local laws that address recording, distribution, transmission, or communication of material or information.
Excluded Scenario: A company engages in an aggressive telemarketing campaign, making unsolicited auto-dialed calls to potential customers without their consent. Several individuals sue the company for violating the TCPA. Because the claim arises from the unauthorized telemarketing calls, this exclusion would apply, and the CGL policy would not cover the claim.
Coverage C - Medical Payments
This coverage is designed to provide immediate medical expense payments for bodily injuries that occur on the insured's premises or as a result of the insured's operations, regardless of who is at fault. This is in contrast to Coverage A, which provides coverage for bodily injury and property damage liability but requires that the insured be legally liable for the injury or damage.
Covered Scenario Under Coverage C: A visitor slips and falls on a wet floor at a retail store. The store’s CGL policy has Coverage C for medical payments. The visitor's medical expenses, such as emergency room treatment and follow-up doctor visits, are covered by the policy up to the specified limit, regardless of whether the store is found legally liable for the accident.
Covered Scenario Under Coverage A: If the same visitor sues the retail store, alleging that the store's negligence (e.g., failing to put up a "wet floor" sign) caused the injury, and the store is found legally liable, Coverage A would cover the legal defense costs and any damages awarded to the visitor. However, the visitor's medical expenses would still be initially covered under Coverage C without waiting for the outcome of the lawsuit.
Differences Between Coverage A and Coverage C:
- Fault Requirement:
- Coverage A: Requires the insured to be legally liable for the injury or damage. The policy provides coverage for legal defense costs and any damages awarded.
- Coverage C: Does not require fault. It pays for medical expenses regardless of liability.
- Purpose:
- Coverage A: Intended to cover the insured’s liability for bodily injury or property damage to third parties.
- Coverage C: Intended to provide immediate medical expense payments to injured persons to help prevent potential lawsuits and promote goodwill.
- Coverage Limits:
- Coverage A: Typically has higher limits, covering extensive legal costs and damages.
- Coverage C: Usually has lower limits, specifically for medical expenses only.
- Type of Expenses Covered:
- Coverage A: Covers a broad range of liabilities, including legal defense, settlements, and judgments.
- Coverage C: Specifically covers medical expenses related to bodily injuries.
In summary, Coverage C in the CGL policy provides immediate, no-fault medical payments for injuries sustained on the insured’s premises or as a result of the insured’s operations, while Coverage A covers the insured’s legal liability for bodily injury and property damage, requiring proof of fault or negligence. Coverage C helps to address minor injuries quickly and efficiently, potentially reducing the likelihood of lawsuits, while Coverage A provides more extensive protection against significant liability claims.
